Lehr's Prime Market catering is casual and completely customizable specifically with your needs in mind. Check out our sample menus.

Casual Catering

Lehr's Prime Market's professional catering staff creatively customizes the perfect food choices for your specific needs from appetizers and quick pick-ups to soup, salad and sandwich displays. Don't forget Group Grill-outs and Pig Roasts. All menu's are purely food for thoughts!  

We will design with you in mind! 

Group Catering...  

Count on LEHR'S PRIME MARKET to make your next Team Dinner, Teacher Appreciation, Working Lunch, Open House, Client Luncheon, Realtor Walk-through, PTO Meeting, Shower, Birthday Party, Reunion, Hospitality Function, Milestone Event & Party of any Proportion... TASTY & TROUBLE-FREE!

~Please talk to our professional catering staff to customize an opportunity perfect for your specific needs!~ 

~In order for us to accommodate you appropriately, confirmation is required no later than 48 hours in advance.~


Ala Carte Options

Soup or Chili Family-Style:     $79.99     Serves 30
2 Gallons of your choice of:        
Tomato Basil Soup
Vegetarian Vegetable
Beef Barley
Chicken Noodle
Corn Chowder
  PRIME Chili
White Chicken Chili
Vegetarian Chili


Please feel free to request another. We will do our best to accommodate!

Salad Family-Style:     $45.00     Serves 30
PRIME Salad:   Caesar Salad:    
Mixed Fresh Greens
Shredded Carrots
Dried Cranberries
Feta Cheese

  Fresh Romaine
Shredded Parmesan
Chef-made Croutons
Chef-made Caesar Dressing

Served with:
(2) Chef-made Dressings
of your choice

  Add (per quote):

Sandwich Platter Options


LPM Mixed Deli Sandwich Platter: $50
Serves 10 (20 half-sandwich triangles)
Your choice of a single or combination of up to 3 types of sandwich triangles 

Premium Deli Meat Options:

     Schad's Ham
Bernard's Turkey Breast
Deluxe Bologna
LEHR'S Famous Rare Roast Beef 
Prime Chicken Salad 
+/or Chef-made Ham Salad
Klosterman's Bread Selection:   White, Wheat, Light or Dark Rye
PRIME Cheese Selections:

  Amish Swiss
+/or Jumping Jack
+/or Land-O-Lakes American
Fixins'... Choice of:

Route 50 Spiced Mayonnaise
Yellow Mustard
Spicy Mustard
Add:   $5.00 for Servatti's Breads
$10.00 for Artisan Breads

Premier MINI Sandwich Platter: $60
Serves 10 (20 Minis per platter)
Your choice of a single or combination of up to 3 types of sandwich minis. 

Spiced Mini Ham Sammies:
Featuring our PRIME Schad's Shaved Ham & Amish Swiss Cheese. These Spiced Samies are marinated over-night in a sweet yet savory secret concoction!

Chicken Salad & Arugula Mini Croissants:
Our much-requested Chicken Salad is kicked up a notch with the addition of slightly peppery Arugula and Mini French Croissants... Voila!

Pulled Pork Sliders:
Nuthin' beats the finger-lickng goodness of Lehr's PRIME Pulled Pork. The Hot BBQ'd Pork with Savory Sauce sits atop a Slider Bun and is perfectly complimented with a dollop of Chef's Cole Slaw. The combination of hot and cool is mouthwatering!

PRIME Sandwich Platter: $70.00
Serves 10 Deluxe Sandwich(es) on Chef's Choice of Artisan Breads.
Your choice of a single or combination of up to 3 types of sandwich minis. (20 half-sandwiches)

Caprese Sandwich: (Rosie Red)
Chef's Focaccia Bread hosts Ruby Red Roma Tomatoes, Fresh Buffalo Mozarella & Fragrant Sweet Basil... sprinkled with a Balsamic Reduction Drizzle. Honestly, a sandwich hit out of the ballpark!

Turkey Pro Pesto: (The Promont)
The first family of Milford deserves a fresh fabulous sandwich consisting of only the best, okay, lacking a few things as well. Our Thuman's Turkey breast is truly lacking... lacking gluten and anti-biotics! Place our perfect Thumann's Turkey Breast atop a Batard Roll and couple it with Provolone Cheese, Ruby Red Tomatoes and Romaine Lettuce and you will have a Promont Perfect, Top-of-the-Hill Sandwich!

Ham & Swiss: (The Clooney)
The "Swiss" may be neutral but, the Clooney's are not! George has a stand on  everything!  That being said, this sandwich is an ageless classic like Nick and Rosemary... and as fabulous as all three! LEHR'S Schad's Ham has the starring role but shares the spotlight creatively with a perfectly balanced Vienna Bread and the best Swiss Cheese the Amish have to offer. Spiced Mayonnaise and Ruby Red Romas are the supporting cast. The ensemble is continually an award winner!

Gourmet Roast Beef w/Fab Flourish: (OTR)
Lehr's Famous Roast Beef cooked to rare perfection sits atop a unique Telera Bread and is coupled with Carmelized Onions, Muenster Cheese, English Cucumber, Ruby Red Tomatoes, and Horseradish Mayo. A little of the expected with unexpected flourishes...  just like OVER THE RHINE!


Ala Cart Sweet Stage


Cookie du Jour: $1.00 pp
Chef's Choice of Cookie of the Day. May include PRIME P'nut Butter, Classic Chocolate Chunk, Our Oatmeal and more! 

Assorted Fancies: $1.00 pp
Assorted specialty pick-ups including Mini Cheescake Bites, Key Lime Diamonds, Tirimisu Minis, Lemon Squares, Cookies 'n Cream Cresents, Turtle Cheesecake Swirls, and more.... assortment varies!

© Copyright 2019 Legend Web Works, LLC