Menus

Lehr's Prime Market catering is casual and completely customizable specifically with your needs in mind. Check out our sample menus.

Great Grillin'

Lehr's Prime Market has the main course plus all of the fixins' for your big parties including: Pig-Out, Steak-Out, Grill-Out, Ribs & Chicken, and Deli Buffet

 

Pig-Out

60 Guest Minimum

 
  • Whole Roasted Pig (initial grilling at Lehr's)
  • Roasted Pig ~ Pit BBQ Finished On-Site
  • Carved & Pulled On-Site
  • Buns & BBQ Sauce
  • TBD Sides
  • Disposable Plateware & Flatware
  • Pit Boss
  • Catering Set-up & Service
  • Service Tables
  • Appropriate Linens & Buffet Pieces
  • Set-up & Strike

Traditional Sides*

Potato Salad ~OR~ Macaroni Salad:
Potato Salads are choice of Mayo OR Mustard based w/ cubed potatoes        
Macaroni Salad is Mayonnaise based w/ Elbow Macaroni

Chopped Cole Slaw:
Finely Chopped Cabbagge with traditional Cole Slaw Dressing 

BBQ Baked Beans:
Baking Beans in mild BBQ Sauce w/ added Brown Sugar

* These Traditional Sides have been customer-favorites for years.


PRIME Sides*

Prime Pasta:
Italian Rusticella Fuscilli Pasta w/ Ruby Red Cherry Tomatoes, Farm Fresh Peas & Thick Cut Bacon Crumbles finished with a Chef-prepared Ranch Dressing.

Prime Slaw:
Shredded Cabbage, Julienne Carrots, and Chef's Special Cole Slaw Dressing.... with or without a thick-cut Bacon Garnish.

Bayless Baked Beans:
3 kinds of Beans, Poblano & Green Bell Peppers, Onions, Brown Sugar, Whole Grain Mustard & Chef's favorite BBQ Sauce 

* Prime Sides are Chef-Derived and Prepared at Lehr's.


Pig-Out w/Traditional Sides: $18.95 per person

UNCOOKED PIG ONLY:
75 lbs. or more: $4.50 per pound
under 75 lbs: $5.99 per pound 

ROASTING GRILL RENTAL:
$100.00 based upon availability


Pig-Out w/PRIME Sides: $21.55 per person

COOKED PIG ONLY:
$300.00 PLUS the price of the pig
75 lbs. or more: $4.50 per pound
under 75 lbs:  $5.99 per pound

LEHR'S PRIME PIG-OUT....SO GOOD IT WILL MAKE YOU SQUEAL!

 
 

Steak-Out

60 Guest Minimum

 

MOOOOVE over Jeff Ruby... Lehr's Prime Market brings the Best Steaks to You!

Perfectly Seasoned! Expertly Grilled on-site! Savvy Sides! Effortless Entertaining!

  • 12 oz. Rib Eye Steaks +/or New York Strip Steaks Grilled On-Site
  • Sauteed Mushrooms & Onions from the Grill
  • TBD Sides
  • Dinner Rolls & Butter
  • Disposable Plateware & Flatware
  • BBQ Boss
  • Catering Set-up & Service
  • Service Tables
  • Appropriate Linens & Buffet Pieces
  • Set-up & Strike

Traditional Sides*
Steak-Out w/Traditional Sides: 
$29.95 per person

Potato Salad ~OR~ Macaroni Salad:
Potato Salads are choice of Mayo OR Mustard based w/ cubed potatoes        
Macaroni Salad is Mayonnaise based w/ Elbow Macaroni

Chopped Cole Slaw:
Finely Chopped Cabbagge with traditional Cole Slaw Dressing

BBQ Baked Beans:
Baking Beans in mild BBQ Sauce w/ added Brown Sugar

* These Traditional Sides have been customer-favorites for years.


PRIME Sides*
Steak-Out w/PRIME Sides: $32.45 per person

Prime Pasta:
Italian Rusticella Fuscilli Pasta w/ Ruby Red Cherry Tomatoes, Farm Fresh Peas & Thick Cut Bacon Crumbles finished with a Chef-prepared Ranch Dressing.

Prime Slaw:  
Shredded Cabbage, Julienne Carrots and Chef's Special Cole Slaw Dressing.... with or without a thick-cut Bacon Garnish.

Bayless Baked Beans:  
3 kinds of Beans, Poblano & Green Bell Peppers, Onions, Brown Sugar, Whole Grain Mustard & Chef's favorite BBQ Sauce 

* Prime Sides are Chef-Derived and Prepared at Lehr's. A PRIME new tradition! 

 

Grill-Out

60 Guest Minimum

 

Voted Best Grilling Meats in 2010!
Still the Greatest Grilling Meats in town!
Lehr's Prime Grilling Meats are all natural, no fillers!  
LPM makes more than 20 varieties of Fresh Brats & Sausages every week!
Our Ground Products are Freshly Ground on-site every day!

  • 1/4 # Freshly Ground Chuck, Hand-Pattied Hamburgers Grilled On-Site
  • 1/4 # Freshly Ground Chuck, Hand-Pattied Cheeseburgers Grilled On-Site
  • Wastler's White Bratwurst
  • Smoked Mettwurst
  • Premium Hot Dogs
  • Sauteed Onions & Peppers from the Grill
  • Assorted Buns
  • TBD Sides
  • Grill Master
  • Disposable Plateware & Flatware
  • Catering Set-up & Service
  • Service Tables
  • Appropriate Linens & Buffet Pieces
  • Set-up & Strike

Traditional Sides*
Grill-Out w/Traditional Sides: $17.95 per person

Potato Salad ~OR~ Macaroni Salad:
Potato Salads are choice of Mayo OR Mustard based w/ cubed potatoes 
Macaroni Salad is Mayonnaise based w/ Elbow Macaroni

Chopped Cole Slaw:
Finely Chopped Cabbagge with traditional Cole Slaw Dressing

BBQ Baked Beans:
Baking Beans in mild BBQ Sauce w/ added Brown Sugar

* These Traditional Sides have been customer-favorites for years


PRIME Sides*
Grill-Out w/Prime Sides: $20.45 per person

Prime Pasta:
Italian Rusticella Fuscilli Pasta w/ Ruby Red Cherry Tomatoes, Farm Fresh Peas & Thick Cut Bacon Crumbles finished with a Chef-prepared Ranch Dressing.

Prime Slaw:  
Shredded Cabbage, Julienne Carrots and Chef's Special Cole Slaw Dressing.... with or without a thick-cut Bacon Garnish.

Bayless Baked Beans:  
3 kinds of Beans, Poblano & Green Bell Peppers, Onions, Brown Sugar, Whole Grain Mustard & Chef's favorite BBQ Sauce 

* Prime Sides are Chef-Derived and Prepared at Lehr's. A PRIME new tradition! 

 

Back Backs & Chicken Breasts

60 Guest Minimum

 
  • Smithfield Baby Back Ribs (extra tender... membrane removed)
  • Bone-in, Skin-on Amish Chicken Breasts (no hormones, antibiotic-free, free-range)
  • BBQ Sauce on Ribs
  • Chef's Route 50 Seasoning on Chicken
  • Assorted Dinner Rolls
  • TBD Sides
  • Disposable Plateware & Flatware
  • BBQ Boss
  • Catering Set-up & Service
  • Service Tables
  • Appropriate Linens & Buffet Pieces
  • Set-up & Strike

 

Traditional Sides*
Back Backs & Chicken Breasts w/Traditional Sides: $18.95 per person

Potato Salad ~OR~ Macaroni Salad:
Potato Salads are choice of Mayo OR Mustard based w/ cubed potatoes 
Macaroni Salad is Mayonnaise based w/ Elbow Macaroni

Chopped Cole Slaw:
Finely Chopped Cabbagge with traditional Cole Slaw Dressing

BBQ Baked Beans:
Baking Beans in mild BBQ Sauce w/ added Brown Sugar

* These Traditional Sides have been customer-favorites for years


PRIME Sides*
Back Backs & Chicken Breasts w/Prime Sides: $21.45 per person

Prime Pasta:
Italian Rusticella Fuscilli Pasta w/ Ruby Red Cherry Tomatoes, Farm Fresh Peas & Thick Cut Bacon Crumbles finished with a Chef-prepared Ranch Dressing.

Prime Slaw:  
Shredded Cabbage, Julienne Carrots and Chef's Special Cole Slaw Dressing.... with or without a thick-cut Bacon Garnish.

Bayless Baked Beans:  
3 kinds of Beans, Poblano & Green Bell Peppers, Onions, Brown Sugar, Whole Grain Mustard & Chef's favorite BBQ Sauce 

* Prime Sides are Chef-Derived and Prepared at Lehr's. A PRIME new tradition! 


Substitute Skinless or Boneless Breasts and/or Amish Fryer Pieces. Just Ask! Market Price

 

Pulled Chicken & Pulled Pork BBQ

60 Guest Minimum

 
  • All White-Meat Amish Chicken Breasts Hand-Pulled (w our Sweet & Saucy BBQ Sauce)
  • Lehr's PRIME Pulled Pork BBQ (w/ a special mix of Cattleman's BBQ Sauce and our Chef's Secret Spicy Sauce)
  • Appropriate Buns
  • TBD Sides
  • Disposable Plateware & Flatware
  • Catering Set-up & Service
  • Service Tables
  • Appropriate Linens & Buffet Pieces
  • Set-up & Strike

Traditional Sides*
Pulled Chicken & Pulled Pork BBQ w/Traditional Sides: $12.95 per person

Potato Salad ~OR~ Macaroni Salad:
Potato Salads are choice of Mayo OR Mustard based w/ cubed potatoes 
Macaroni Salad is Mayonnaise based w/ Elbow Macaroni

Chopped Cole Slaw:
Finely Chopped Cabbagge with traditional Cole Slaw Dressing

BBQ Baked Beans:
Baking Beans in mild BBQ Sauce w/ added Brown Sugar

* These Traditional Sides have been customer-favorites for years


PRIME Sides*
Pulled Chicken & Pulled Pork BBQ w/Prime Sides: $15.45 per person

Prime Pasta:
Italian Rusticella Fuscilli Pasta w/ Ruby Red Cherry Tomatoes, Farm Fresh Peas & Thick Cut Bacon Crumbles finished with a Chef-prepared Ranch Dressing.

Prime Slaw:  
Shredded Cabbage, Julienne Carrots and Chef's Special Cole Slaw Dressing.... with or without a thick-cut Bacon Garnish.

Bayless Baked Beans:  
3 kinds of Beans, Poblano & Green Bell Peppers, Onions, Brown Sugar, Whole Grain Mustard & Chef's favorite BBQ Sauce 

* Prime Sides are Chef-Derived and Prepared at Lehr's. A PRIME new tradition! 


Prefer ALL Pulled Chicken or ALL Pulled Pork BBQ? Just Ask! Market Price

 

Prime Deli Cuts Classic Buffet

60 Guest Minimum

 

Lehr's PRIME Market has the best of the best deli meats. We don't follow a product line but have spent years taste-testing and perfecting our selection to offer you only the very best! Amish, Gluten-Free, Hormone and Antibiotic-Free! Amazingly Fresh! We promise you only the very best!

Display trays of:

  • Oven Roasted Amish Turkey
  • Lehr's PRIME Rare Roast Beef - cooked at Lehr's
  • Schad's Ham
  • Land 'O Lake's American Cheese
  • Amish Swiss Cheese
  • Mayonnaise
  • Mustard
  • TBD Breads
  • TBD Sides

Traditional Sides*
Deli Cuts Classic Buffet w/Traditional Sides & Klosterman's Breads: $13.95 per person

Potato Salad ~OR~ Macaroni Salad:
Potato Salads are choice of Mayo OR Mustard based w/ cubed potatoes 
Macaroni Salad is Mayonnaise based w/ Elbow Macaroni

Chopped Cole Slaw:
Finely Chopped Cabbagge with traditional Cole Slaw Dressing

BBQ Baked Beans:
Baking Beans in mild BBQ Sauce w/ added Brown Sugar

Klosterman's Breads

* These Traditional Sides have been customer-favorites for years


PRIME Sides*
Deli Cuts Classic Buffet w/Prime Sides & Servatii's Breads: $16.95 per person

Prime Pasta:
Italian Rusticella Fuscilli Pasta w/ Ruby Red Cherry Tomatoes, Farm Fresh Peas & Thick Cut Bacon Crumbles finished with a Chef-prepared Ranch Dressing.

Prime Slaw:  
Shredded Cabbage, Julienne Carrots and Chef's Special Cole Slaw Dressing.... with or without a thick-cut Bacon Garnish.

Bayless Baked Beans:  
3 kinds of Beans, Poblano & Green Bell Peppers, Onions, Brown Sugar, Whole Grain Mustard & Chef's favorite BBQ Sauce 

Servatii's Breads

* Prime Sides are Chef-Derived and Prepared at Lehr's. A PRIME new tradition!

Add our Seasonal Brats to any order!

Freshly made on-site: Sheboygan Brats, Cheese Brats, Beer Brats, Sweet Italian Sausage, Hot Italian Sausage, Philly Cheese Steak Brats, Hungarian Sausage, Parmesan Garlic Brats, Sweet Pepper & Onion Brats, Tomato Basil Brats, Hoppin' Jalapeno & Habenero Brats, Mild Jalapeno Cheddar Brats, Zippy Grub Shack Brats, Shanghai Sausage, Polish Kielbasa, Bloody Mary Brats, Mushroom & Swiss Chicken Brats, Buffalo Bleu Chicken Brats, Zesty Chicken Brats, Carribean Jerk Chicken Brats, Turkey & Cranberry Brats w/ Gran Marnier

© Copyright 2018 Legend Web Works, LLC